Is it morning in Michigan again? Education reform advocates hope so.
President Ronald Reagan’s famous 1984 campaign advertisement touted a positive economic turnaround and an upbeat American morale. “[O]ur country is prouder and stronger and better,” narrated the Great Communicator. Given the recent recession and accompanied woes, another national jolt is in order.
In a much-anticipated move, this month the Michigan House of Representatives voted to lift the charter school cap. State Senators had initiated the process through the passage of a similar bill. The two chambers have reconciled the differences; it awaits the approval of Governor Rick Snyder (R-MI).
Incrementally, state-funded universities would have the authority to sponsor and approve more charters. The highlight of the legislative bundle, entitled the “parental empowerment package,” boasts an allowance of up to 300 charter schools in 2012 and an additional 200 the following year. Beginning in 2015, an unlimited amount will be allowed to prosper under state law.
Critics – including the Michigan Education Association, a liberal teachers union – claim that these alternative educational options perform worse than government-run entities and provide an avenue for profit.
But charter schools are held to a higher standard. If they fail to meet a set of stricter-than-average criteria, their charter is not renewed. Public schools can barely scrape by for years without any scrutiny, under-performing teachers are granted tenure, and families fall behind as a result. The statistics speak for themselves, especially for urban areas: charter school students have higher attendance, academic performance, and graduation rates than their public counterparts (2009 Education Report, Mackinac Center for Public Policy). It is as simple as that.
In the opinion of the Michigan Council of Charter School Authorizers, “SB 618 raises academic standards for all charter public schools by strengthening accountability on academic performance; fiscal management; and transparency for schools, operators and authorizers.” They added that “[f]or the first time in state law, this bill will require demonstrated improved academic achievement for all groups of students as the most important factor for charter contract renewal.”
State Representative Tom McMillin (R-MI), Chairman of the House Education Committee, released a statement after the successful effort in Lansing: “Michigan’s children should not have to wait for adults in government to remove limits on their future. By phasing out this arbitrary, outdated cap today, thousands of students currently on charter school waiting lists were given real hope for a better tomorrow” (HuffPost Detroit, 12/14/11).
Senate Bill 618 passed almost entirely along party lines, 20-18 in the originating chamber and 58-49 in the House. Republicans, whom have majorities in both chambers for the first time since 2006, were able to usher in commonsense education reform despite Democrat pushback. Left-wing petty political tactics notwithstanding, status quo reluctance to innovation in the classroom is no more.
Under the new legislative measure, many more students will now have the opportunity to obtain a specialized education. The free-market approach is a proven solution to such complicated and important issues as education. Successful charter schools that meet tough requirements shall flourish far into the future, while the unsuccessful fade away. By offering a chance for outside-the-box thinking to shine, children receive the attention they deserve.
Is the sun rising on Michigan’s future? Time will tell. A giant step in the right direction, though, makes for a beautiful scene.
National School Choice Week (NSCW), scheduled for January 22-28, is an initiative intended to spark conversation and brainstorm ideas for expanding opportunities for America’s kids. Everyone can make a genuine difference toward our future today. Visit www.SchoolChoiceWeek.com for further information including details on how to get involved.
Nicholas Kowalski writes for NSCW, maintains an active Twitter handle (@NKowalski), and can be reached via NicholasKowalski.com.